Confirmed.
(Even without seeing your FreeCAD infos.)
Confirmed.
Me too, besides it's my first time using FreeCAD, but good luck to achieve the same Loundspeaker performance using a different sketch.Bance wrote: ↑Sat Oct 01, 2022 4:26 pmI agree I don't have a clue about loudspeakers, I do however know a bit about sketches.lordsansui wrote: ↑Sat Oct 01, 2022 3:50 pm Looks like you don't know the requirements needed for a loundspeaker.
Thank you for helping, Once I can't PAD one after another and PAD them all together has the same issue, I see no other option, maybe I need to disable something anywhere. Could you indicate me the right order?
You won't find anything about "order" I suspect. The people here are using the term "order", because the workflow you've chosen (master/master-subset sketches) means the sequence you pad things in will determine if the Pad operation will work or fail.lordsansui wrote: ↑Sat Oct 01, 2022 6:19 pm ...
I'm going to check again to find something in the official documentation, at least in the PAD section, link below, there is no clear indication about order.
...
Thank you a lot Roy, now I understood clearly, the solid created by the PAD must be in contact each other to be identified as a single solid, so the first model I mad I was just lucky that the sequence I used respect the rule, while in the second one not.Roy_043 wrote: ↑Sat Oct 01, 2022 6:52 pm Please look at this simplified example:
If you pad the red sketch first, you cannot pad the white sketch second, as there would then be two solids with a gap.
Please also read Part_and_PartDesign.
I'm not an audiophile, but I'm engineer, and there is reasons for things to exist and to be done in a specific way, you liking it or not, and criticizing my sketch not knowing in the first place the reasons behind it isn't wise from your side. The help request was related to PAD issue. Is't not a problem if you don't like my sketch, it's just that you can hold this option for yourself if it doesn't contribute to fix the issue.